Batan Island Visitors Guide

Written by Patrick


Travel Insurance


Batan is the main island and the second largest island in the archipelagic province of Batanes.  The municipality of Basco, the provincial capital of Batanes, is located on Batan Island. Batan is also home to three other municipalities namely Ivana, Mahatao, and Uyugan.

Being the main island and the provincial capital, Batan is the primary entry point to many other islands of the majestic Batanes province.  The island has volcanoes, scenic rolling hills, iconic lighthouses, stone churches and houses, towering cliffs, and many others.

This brief guide to Batan Island will help you plan your trip. It contains information on what to do, eat, and drink as well as the must-see spots and the best hotels.


Batan Island Location Map

Best Time to Visit

It’s best to visit the Philippines during the dry season.  Dry season in the Philippines spans from November through April.  These are the summer months in this country.

Be aware that temperatures and humidity levels are particularly high in April and May.

The best time to be a beach bum and explore the islands is from March to May.

TIP:  We recommend that booking for Batan Island summer trips should be done as early as possible, at least a month before your travel dates, since resorts get fully booked early.

The period from June to October is the rainy (wet) season and is best avoided due to the high possibility of typhoons. The typhoons can not only be destructive, but most tours and activities are cancelled under such circumstances.  Transportation via plane and boat is also seriously impacted as well.  This happens frequently so beware!

We recommend traveling to Batan Island in April-May or in November-December, just before and just after the rainy season. This will likely bring fewer crowds, yet pleasant weather, and is also a great time to score a travel deal.

Fast Facts

Destination Name:
Batan Island
Local Time:
Best Time of Year to Visit:
December – May
Approximately 14,007
English, Ivatan, Ilocano, Tagalog
Philippine Peso (PHP)
Exchange Rate:
Approximately 1 USD = 50 PHP click for exact exchange rate
Geographic Coordinates:
20°25′17″N 121°57′37″E
95.18 km2 (36.75 sq mi)
Neighboring Cities:
Neighboring Islands:
Sabtang Island | Vohas Island
Lightweight casuals
Catholicism (majority), other Christian churches
Best Known For:
Rolling hills and stone houses
Major Industries:
Farming and agriculture
Standard voltage is 220V
Plug commonly used is Type A but Types B and C are used as well. Bring A to B adapter(s).
International Phone Code:
Airport & Airport Code:
Basco Seaport | Port of Ivana
Bus Terminal(s):

Getting Here

There are many ways to get here depending on your starting point. We recommend using the following online tools to identify all the available options and cost for each while on Batan Island:  Rome2Rio and PHBUS. The following are the major ports of entry for this destination.



Basco Airport


Bus Terminal




Basco Seaport

PH Bus

Getting Around

The following are the modes of transportation available on Batan Island …





Motorized Outrigger

Motorized Outrigger



Rome to Rio


The following are the places to see and activities to enjoy while on Batan Island.

1 | Mount Iraya

One of the active volcanoes in the country, Mount Iraya is the highest point in Batanes.  This landmark significant to Ivatan folklore has an elevation of 1,009 meters and is quite steep with a narrow trail which can get muddy and slippery.  It has thick forests and the top is often covered in clouds therefore obscuring the view below and also causing moisture that makes the trail muddy.  Hiking to the summit takes 3 to 4 hours and the descent is approximately about 3 hours.  Mount Iraya is recommended for experienced hikers.

2 | Rolling Hills

Batanes, particularly Batan Island, is known for the picturesque rolling hills.  The Vayang Rolling Hills, with its different shades of green where livestock graze, provides an unobstructed view of the beautiful Mount Iraya.  You can also catch a glimpse of the controversial West Philippine Sea while you’re there.

Rakuh a Payaman, popularly called Marlboro Country, is also a hill covered in greenery where animals such as cows, carabaos, and horses graze freely. The most photographed tourist spot in Batanes, Rakuh a Payaman is a great vantage point of where the land, sea, and sky meet.

As breathtaking as Vayang and Rakuh a Payaman, Chamantad-Tinyan Viewpoint offers a view of the serene beach covered with powdery white sand.

3 | Lighthouses

The province of Batanes may be small but it has three lighthouses, two of which are on Batan Island.  The most popular one is Basco Lighthouse which stands on Naidi Hills where ruins of an old American telegraph tower can be seen up to this day.  The tower, which is 20-meter tall, offers a 360-degree view of Basco and the West Philippine Sea.

The other one is Tayid Lighthouse in Mahatao.  It faces the Pacific Ocean.

4 | Chawa View Deck

Located on one of the highest spots in Batanes, the view deck provides scenic views of the rolling hills, rock formations, the seascape, and the West Philippine Sea.  There’s also a grotto of the Virgin Mary at the top and a winding staircase with more than 100 steps leading down the rocky shore below.

5 | Mount Carmel Church

Mount Carmel, the most photographed church in Batanes, is found in Basco.  While it isn’t really old as it was only opened in 2008, it has become an icon of the province as it has a traditional stone house design.  Also called Tukon Chapel, Mount Carmel has an orange roof and painted interiors.  It stands on top of a hill and provides a view of the Pacific Ocean.

6 | San Jose de Ivana Church

San Jose de Ivana Church is a Roman Catholic church in the town of Ivana.  It was declared a National Historical Landmark by the National Historical Commission due to its foundation which was built in 1775.  The Katipunan flag was waved in the church’s bell tower in 1898.

7 | Dipnaysupuan Japanese Tunnel

Used by the Japanese forces during World War II, Dipnaysupuan Japanese Tunnel is a network of tunnels in Tukon Hills.  The tunnel has four main rooms, a water reservoir, guard post, bunker, and five exits leading to Taytak and Tukon.  The tunnel is open for tourists to explore but with the company of an authorized tour guide.

8 | Stone Houses

Batanes lies in the path of most typhoons hitting the country so having stone houses is one way to prepare for disasters.  Stone houses in Batanes are made of cobbles and mortar with thick limestone walls and thatched cogon roofs.  One of the most popular stone houses is the House of Dakay which was built in 1887 and is considered as the oldest stone house in the province.  Other houses to see well-preserved old stone houses include Chavayan, Savidug Village, and Sinakan Village.

9 | Mahatao Boat Shelter

Mahatao Boat Shelter was constructed to protect the boats from the erratic weather of Batanes.  While there is nothing much to do here, you may want to stop for a few minutes to enjoy the beautiful scenery and take photos that, given the right angle, can look like they were taken in the Mediterranean.

10 |  Ivana Honesty Coffee Shop

Just across Ivana Church is Ivana Honesty Coffee Shop, the most popular sari-sari store in Batanes.  The store is unmanned, and prices are only listed on the counter so buyers know how much money to leave in the box provided.  It is how it got its name.

NOTE: The Palo-palo Festival occurs annually on Batan Island every 24th of July.



The following are the restaurants to try while on Batan Island.

1 | Vunong Dinette At Jessica’s Place

Vunong Dinette At Jessica’s Place is the best spot if you want to experience authentic Ivatan cuisine.  A garage turned into a restaurant, Vunong Dinette has a quaint setting and homey ambience with its wooden interiors and furniture.  Try the traditional Ivatan meal which comprises turmeric rice, luñiz, uvud balls, fish and beef, all wrapped in a large breadfruit leaf called vunong.  Making a reservation at least one day in advance is highly recommended.

2 | Phil’s Brew

Phil’s Brew is a homey little spot in Basco that serves the best coffee in the area as well as pastries and other Ivatan delicacies.  Must-try includes tres leches, chocolate cake, and dukayo (local root crop and sweetened coconut).

3 | Harbour Cafe

As the name implies, the restaurant overlooks the harbour and is also less than a kilometer away from Basco Airport.  Harbour Cafe has a lively and fun vibe brought by its colorful interiors.  While the cafe is small and only has a few tables, it is popular for its ambience, lovely view, and good food.  Harbour Cafe serves favorite comfort foods such as pizza, pasta, and milkshakes. 

4 | Jino’s East Pizzaria

Jino’s is a cozy restaurant beside the Basco lighthouse that serves pizza, pasta, and chicken tenders.  While their garden setting makes the restaurant a favorite place to unwind in Batanes, they also deliver to hotels.

5 | Casa Napoli

The top restaurant in Batanes based on reviews, Casa Napoli serves Italian favorites made of fresh and homegrown ingredients.  The space is small and can accommodate around 12 people at a time so expect to wait to be accommodated when dining during peak hours.  Try their fried chicken, Luñiz pasta (local pork dish), and of course pizza which is what the restaurant is known for.

6 | Octagon Bed and Dine

Open to both guests and non-guests of the hotel, Octagon is a go-to place for local dishes such as bulalo, kare kare, and sinigang.  They have the cheapest lobster in the area too!  All other dishes are reasonably-priced with servings good for two to three persons.  Despite the limited seating capacity, many people still choose Octagon to enjoy both good food and breathtaking views of the West Philippine Sea, Basco Port, and the lighthouse.

7 | Pension Ivatan Hometel and Restaurant

The restaurant is a reliable place to get your fill of Filipino and Asian cuisines.  Located beside the airport, the place is a favorite among tourists especially those who are traveling with companions since the serving of most dishes is good for two to three people.  Try their Ivatan platter, coconut crab, and lobster.

8 | Cafe du Tukon

Standing on a hilltop, Cafe du Tukon offers a stunning view of the green rolling hills and the sea.  Apart from the view and the relaxing ambience, the restaurant serves quality foods made of organic ingredients grown and raised by the local farmers.  The price may be higher for local standards but considering the quality and the benefits for local farmers, it’s worth it in the end.  Don’t miss their paella, pasta, and chocolate mousse.

9 | Hiro’s Cafe

Hiro’s Cafe specializes in Ivatan foods but also serves other Filipino favorites.  The restaurant has a simple carinderia-style setup yet considered one of the best in the province.  Try their tapa, escargot (native snails harvested from the forest), Luñiz (Batanes adobo), organic pork tocino, and dried flying fish.

10 | Beehan’s Meals & Snack

Beehan’s Meals & Snack is a simple yet cozy restaurant serving local dishes like beef nilaga (beef soup), pork humba, sinigang, sisig, and kinilaw which is not always available as it gets sold out immediately.  The food is reasonably priced hence a good option for those who are on a limited budget.

KNOWN FOR: Uved balls, made of grated banana corm and mixed with ground pork or beef and minced fish.


There are many different types of accommodations available in this destination ranging from hostels to luxurious resorts. The following are our top choices for each range on Batan Island.

1 | Den Den Guesthouse (Budget)

2 | Baletin Hometel (Mid-Range)

3 | Bernardo’s Lantia Hotel (Luxury | Resort)

We recommend using the following sites to conduct research online of where to stay on Batan Island or for a specific destination:

Book your room with these trusted online booking sites.  Booking online in the Philippines almost always guarantees the best price and a room when you arrive.  We use these sites frequently to get the best prices and enjoy convenient bookings. Click each of the buttons below to find the best place for you at the lowest rates:

TIP: Baletin Hometel is the best property to experience this destination.


Suggested Budget

Use the chart below to get an idea of how much to budget daily.  Actual amounts will depend on YOUR travel style. Keep in mind these are daily averages … some days you’ll spend more, some days you’ll spend less. Prices are in USD.

Accommodation: $12
Food: $8
Transportation: $5
Attractions: $25
Average Daily Cost: $50
Accommodation: $35
Food: $15
Transportation: $10
Attractions: $30
Average Daily Cost: $90
Accommodation: $145
Food: $35
Transportation: $20
Attractions: $40
Average Daily Cost: $240

Travel Costs


A bed in a hostel dorm costs from 350 PHP ($7 USD), but smaller dorms can cost from 500 PHP ($10 USD).  For a private double, prices start around 700 PHP ($14 USD).

Most budget hotels begin at 700 PHP ($14 USD) per night for a double room and usually include free wifi and breakfast.  For a three-star hotel, prices begin around 1,400 PHP ($28 USD) per night.  AirBnB is also widespread throughout the country, with private rooms starting from as little as 500 PHP ($10 USD) per night.  For entire apartments, expect to pay at least 1,400 PHP ($28 USD) per night.

Resorts and luxury accommodations vary greatly from 1,400 PHP ($28 USD) to 5,000+ PHP ($100+ USD).  However, there are some really nice resorts and luxury accommodations which are surprisingly affordable.

We use and recommend booking online to save money using, and AirBnB. 


Local food is extremely cheap, with street food costing under 50 PHP ($1USD).  For an inexpensive meal at a local restaurant, prices start around 100 PHP ($2 USD).  For a meal at a mid-range restaurant with drinks and table service, expect to pay from 200 PHP ($4 USD).  Knowing that their target customers are primarily tourists, Western food venues can be pricey compared to Filipino food.  Also, some of the ingredients need to be imported, which contributes to the higher cost. Western food (burgers, pizza, pasta, etc.) is much more expensive but is still relatively affordable at around 200 PHP ($4 USD) for a meal and drink.

Fast food like McDonalds will cost around 200 PHP ($4 USD).  A beer at the bar will cost around 50-100 PHP ($1–2 USD).

A week’s worth of groceries will cost between 300-600 PHP ($6-12 USD) per person.  However, food in this country is so inexpensive, and kitchens & refrigerators are hard to come by, I don’t recommend cooking your meals here since there is plenty of delicious street food to eat at very cheap prices. You won’t make it as good as they do and the food is too delicious to miss!


There are many modes of transportation available in the Philippines and each varies greatly. 

Public Transportation is cheap.  Bus services on the islands are inexpensive.  Local buses (called jeepneys) are the most common type of transportation in towns and cities. The fare is usually between 7-25 PHP ($.20–.50 USD).

On islands without a bus system, a taxi or tricycle is the only form of transport with fares starting at 50-500 PHP ($1-$10) USD for short trips. 

Taxis are everywhere, and they’re very cheap.  Most fares shouldn’t cost you more than 500 PHP ($10 USD) around town.  

To get between islands, you’ll need to take a boat or to fly.  There are ferries that connect the island together since they aren’t too far apart but, generally speaking, flights are the most realistic option. 

Flights between islands usually cost about 2,000-3500 PHP ($40-70 USD).  However, this isn’t the cheapest way to travel.  It’s only recommended if you have limited time. 

We recommend booking online to save money using:

Attractions & Activities

Most attractions and activities in the Philippines are pretty cheap. Most attractions throughout the area are FREE to enter, though some of the more well known and popular ones cost 5-100 PHP ($.10-$2 USD) to enter. 

Depending on the activity, most day tours only cost around 1,000-1,500 PHP ($20-30 USD), oftentimes less.  You have more bargaining power if you go with a group. If you are expecting to do some climbing, remember to pack some warm layers. It gets cold at the top!  

Other activities such as Island Hopping, scuba diving, helmet diving, swimming with whale sharks, jungle trekking, canyoning, ATVs, jet skis, wakeboarding, cruises, parasailing, horseback riding, cultural experiences, and tours can cost as much as 1,250-5,000+ PHP ($25-100+ USD).

The Philippines is one of the least expensive places to learn how to scuba dive. Learning to scuba dive usually costs about 15,000-20,000 PHP ($300-400 USD), but often includes FREE accommodation for the duration of the course, which lasts three or four days.

Always book your tours and activities when you arrive.  Stick to travel agents who are selling on the ground. If a travel agent won’t negotiate with you, move on to the next until you find one that will.  Booking tours online is almost always more expensive. 

Typical Costs on Batan Island in 2023:

  • Budget Hotel:  1,200 PHP ($20 USD) night
  • Mid-Range Hotel:  2,300 PHP ($40 USD) night
  • Street Food: 50-150 PHP ($1–3 USD) meal
  • Restaurant Meals: 200-300 PHP ($4–6 USD) meal
  • Local Beer: 50-100 PHP ($1–2 USD) bottle
  • 1.5L Bottle of Water: 38 PHP ($.75 USD) bottle
  • Tricycle Ride:  20-100 PHP ($.5-2 USD) ride
  • Domestic Flight: 4,000-15,000 PHP ($70–260 USD) flight

DOWNLOAD: Budget Planner Template













The following is some of our best advice on traveling to Batan Island.  Learn what you need to know BEFORE you go!

Tips & Hacks

The following are our Top 10 Tips when visiting this destination in the Philippines:

  • Be aware that a tourist VISA is only 30 days. You can extend it upon arrival, or within the first 30 days, for an additional 30 days for a fee of approximately 3,000 pesos.
  • Don’t buy into the fear factor. The Philippines has an unjustified reputation of being a dangerous place. It’s true there are security guards everywhere, but that is to deter theft.
  • Manila is NOT the Philippines. Get outside of the cities to see the real Philippines.
  • Don’t over plan. Boats, buses, and even airplane schedules are notoriously unreliable. Be flexible.
  • Check the weather. The weather varies greatly throughout the Philippines daily.
  • Typhoons can have a huge impact on your plans. Account for this when planning your trip.
  • It’s not cool to raise your voice or show outward frustration in public.
  • Be polite at all times. Realize that your country’s sense of humor may be different from Filipino humor and take this into account when interacting with Filipinos and while in public places.
  • Things move at a slower pace. Accept it … don’t get frustrated … but do account for it.
  • Don’t drink the tap water… but stay hydrated! Save money by buying large bottles (6-10 liters) of water and using it to fill your water bottle or hydration bladder in your backpack.

For a complete list of our travel tips & hacks, check out the following guide and be sure to download a FREE copy for yourself.

VIEW & DOWNLOAD: The Ultimate Travel Tips & Hacks Guide for the Philippines

Money Matters

The Philippines has its own currency called the Philippine Peso. Banks, ATMs, and money-changers can be found on the island. If you are exploring the neighboring islands or provinces, make sure to bring enough cash that will last until the next time you get to an ATM or bank since most tours, transportation, and budget accommodations only accept cash.

READ MORE: Money in the Philippines: Everything You Need to Know

Health & Safety


While overall the Philippines is a safe country to visit, as is Batan Island, you need to use common sense just as you would in any country, especially when traveling, and in a city, town, or area you are unfamiliar with.

Consult your hotel or resort front desk as they are more likely to give you reliable information than a random stranger on the street. Be careful when approaching strangers and selective about who you approach. Always pay attention to your gut feeling and follow it.

READ MORE: How to Avoid Scams & Thieves in the Philippines


There are many things to consider when traveling in order to stay safe … things that we may not be accustomed to during our normal everyday lives. The following are articles about tips on how to stay safe while traveling in the Philippines:

TIP: The best way to avoid problems and stay safe is to travel with a local resident.


Staying fit & healthy can be challenging when traveling in the Philippines. 

The tropical Philippines climate requires you to prepare for illnesses that you may not normally be accustomed to. 

The following are our Top 10 Tips for Staying Healthy while Traveling in the Philippines:

  • Maintain a Balanced Diet
  • Stay Hydrated but Only Drink Bottled Water
  • Get Plenty of Rest
  • Allow Your Body Time to Adjust 
  • Keep Active
  • Sanitize Often 
  • Be Aware of Food Safety Concerns
  • Take Your Vitamins
  • Practice Safe Sex
  • Be Prepared Should You Get Sick

READ MORE: Stay Healthy in the Philippines: How to Avoid Getting Sick

Staying Connected

You need to have a local-based SIM card in order to stay connected when in the Philippines. Network giants such as Globe and Smart have SIM cards you can use to make calls, send text messages, and also to connect to the Internet. A SIM card costs around 50 PHP ($1 USD) and usually comes with a FREE load worth 50 PHP ($1 USD). You can buy a card containing a code you can enter on your phone to replenish your load or buy an electronic load that is available almost anywhere in the city.

While you may not have problems with signal strength when in the city, it is not always the case when on islands or in remote areas of a province.  So when arranging for transportation pick up, say when renting a boat to take you to and pick you up from the island, it would be best that you make it clear what time you need to be picked up before the boatman leaves.

Recommended Travel Apps

Apps for smartphones and tablets can be useful both before you leave and while you’re traveling.  Most are available for iPhones and Android phones.

The following are our Top 10 most useful travel apps on our smartphones when traveling in the Philippines:

  1. Grab (taxis/ride shares)
  2. Angkas (motorbike ride-hailing)
  3. WhatsApp (phone calls)
  4. Skyscanner (flights)
  5. Rome2Rio (transportation)
  6. Agoda (accomodations)
  7. (accomodations)
  8. AirBnB (accomodations)
  9. Traveloka (flights, accomodations, activities)
  10. Klook (attractions & activities )

Be certain to download and set up apps BEFORE leaving on your trip to make certain each is installed and working properly.

For our complete list of travel apps that we use and recommend while traveling in the Philippines, checkout our checklist below.  Download a FREE copy for yourself as a PDF.

READ MORE: The Ultimate List of Travel Apps for the Philippines


Trying to decide what to do when traveling to a destination for the first time can be a bit overwhelming given your lack of familiarity with the place along with all of the available options. 

We’ve created the following itinerary to help simplify the process and ensure that you get the most out of your trip.  Although we provide a 7 day itinerary for this destination, it can always be adjusted to fit the length of your trip.

VIEW: Batan Island 7-Day Travel Itinerary

Packing Checklist

The secret to a successful and stress-free trip is to start by using a packing list.  This will reduce anxiety from the start and ensure that nothing important is forgotten when packing.   To make this process easy for you, we’ve created a detailed packing list.  Click the link below to download it for FREE now. 

Carrying your checklist with you during your travels can be useful when repacking, by helping to ensure that you do not leave anything behind.

VIEW & DOWNLOAD: Our Ultimate Packing Guide & Checklist

Things to Remember

We recommend taking note of the following while traveling on Batan Island or in the Philippines in general.


There is a nationwide ban which prohibits smoking in public places including indoors, the streets, on sidewalks, in restaurants , and on public transportation, requiring smokers to use designated smoking areas.  Selling tobacco to and purchasing from or for minors is also prohibited. Violators are subject to fines (up to 5,000 PHP | $100 USD) and even 4 months in prison.


The minimum legal drinking age is 18.  Alcohol such as beer and hard drinks can easily be bought in grocery and convenience stores.  The most common alcoholic beverage is beer, generally served cold.  Local alcoholic drinks include tuba (coconut wine which is usually very strong) and potent moonshine-like clear liquors made from sugar or fruit.  Imported beer, wine, and name brand hard alcohol are available but expensive.


Drugs are illegal in the Philippines.  Don’t use, buy, or sell any non-prescription drugs while in the Philippines … not even marijuana.  It is considered an especially heinous crime to buy from, for, or sell drugs to children.  The penalties are severe … up to and including death.


Public nudity is illegal in the Philippines and is not tolerated.  Most locals consider it offensive.  There are laws which prohibit provocative and erotic clothing and swimwear, therefore carefully consider your clothings and swimwear choices to make certain they are not too revealing.

Foreigners & Expats

If you are not a Filipino citizen, remember that you are a guest when visiting this country … be certain to act accordingly.  Respect the people, their customs, and the environment and wlidlife. You can be deported and banned … so behave … but have fun and enjoy all that this wonderful destination has to offer.

READ MORE: Practical Information about the Philippines



I always carry a Camelbak Hydration Pack with me when traveling. Not only does it allow me to pack all my daily gear and snacks, but it also has a 3-liter water bladder which holds enough water to get me through the entire day.

Bluetooth Speaker

Compact yet mighty, a bluetooth speaker setup is a breeze, and the sound quality it delivers for its size is nothing short of impressive. Beyond its audio prowess, it boasts exceptional durability, making it an ideal companion for outdoor adventures.

UV Shirt

UV Shirt is an essential when travelling in a tropical country. Providing reliable protection during long hours in the water, not only comfortable but also ensures a secure shield against the elements.

Snorkel Gear

For my island-hopping escapades, a snorkel gear set has become indispensable. Designed to enhance the joy of snorkeling and free diving, each piece ensures comfort and functionality. Together, they create an immersive and enjoyable underwater experience.

Adventure Camera

As a long-time enthusiast of GoPro cameras, I can attest to their user-friendly nature, excellent image stabilization, and impressive footage quality. Waterproof and rugged, the GoPro is my reliable companion for capturing adventures in any environment.

Aqua Shoes

When it comes to beach footwear, aqua shoes offer exceptional support, breathability, and overall comfort. Well-crafted and sturdy, it provides effective protection against rocky terrain, quick drying for added convenience, and easy maintenance. A must-have for any outdoor enthusiast.


Don’t Forget …

Download Our FREE Travel Guides

We have dozens of guides to destinations throughout the Philippines. Download your FREE copy for your next trip today.

Philippine Travel Guides


Do you live on this island or have YOU visited it?

About the Author


Patrick is an entrepreneur, digital nomad, explorer, and photographer. Patrick is always in search of fun and adventure. He is well travelled throughout the world, and although location independent, his home base is Phoenix, Arizona in the USA. Patrick loves island lifestyle which is no wonder why he is so interested in spending time in the Philippines with it’s over 7,000 islands. Patrick created this site to share his knowledge of and experiences in the Philippines with Filipinos as well as other foreigners.

Leave a Comment